ࡱ> "$ !%` bjbjٕ .:b%dOdOdO8O4PT0R0R"RRRRRR-S-S-S$hLAw[-S-Sw[w[ARRRRV]]]w[dRRRR]w[]]J\RR$R BdO[dGB_l06f?\Bff#-S|U]oWlX-S-S-SAA]X-S-S-Sw[w[w[w[399 MINUTES UAF FACULTY SENATE MEETING #166 Monday, April 5, 2010 1:00 p.m. 3:17 p.m. Wood Center Ballroom I Call to Order Jonathan Dehn Faculty Senate President Jonathan Dehn called the meeting to order at 1:00 p.m. A. Roll Call for 2009-10 Faculty Senate Members Present:Members Present (contd): Others Present:ABRAMOWICZ, KenWEBER, JaneGuest: Mark HamiltonALLEN, JaneWILSON, TimothyANGER, AndyBAKER, CarrieMembers Absent:BARTLETT, ChristaDONG, LilyBOGOSYAN, SetaFOWELL, SarahBROCIOUS, Heidi (audio)JIN, MeibingCAHILL, CathyJOLIE, JulyCHRISTIE, Anne (Karen Jensen)KERR, MarianneDAVIS, MikeLIANG, JingjingDEHN, JonathanPALTER, MorrisGANGULI, Rajive (audio)RALONDE, RayHANSEN, RogerHAZIRBABA, KenanNon-voting Members Present:HOCK, RegineTim Stickel (audio)HUETTMANN, Falk (audio)Denis WiesenburgKADEN, UtePete PinneyKONAR, BrendaMartin KleinKOUKEL, Sonja (audio)Brian RogersLARDON, CecileSusan HenrichsLAWLOR, OrionLEONARD, Beth (audio)McEACHERN, Diane (audio)MCINTYRE, JulieNEWBERRY, RainerREYNOLDS, JenniferROBERTS, LarryTHOMAS, Amber B. Approval of Minutes to Meeting #165 The minutes were approved as distributed, with one correction to attendance. C. Adoption of Agenda The agenda was adopted with one amendment: Public Comments will be taken before Break during the first hour of the meeting. II Status of Chancellor's Office Actions A. Motions Approved: 1. Motion to Amend the Mandatory Placement Policy B. Motions Pending: None III A. President's Comments Jonathan Dehn Jon thanked all present for bearing with them during the difficult election process and for helping to resolve the concerns the minority had about the voting process to extend their terms. Both he and Cathy are honored that the supermajority has voted (twice) to extend their terms. He hopes to get an excellent president-elect candidate for the next election and will immediately start on that effort after todays meeting. The System Academic Council has met regarding the distance education audit, and is working on plans to streamline distance education between the three campuses, aiming to make it more transparent to the students. Also, the Academic Master Plan is on the agenda for faculty suggestions and discussion. Faculty Alliance is preparing for a change of leadership. Theyve also been working with SAC on the Academic Master Plan, and the Alliance wants to take the feedback from the three senates, synthesize it into a form supportive of the plan, which would then be shared with the Board of Regents. Jons also been working with the UAF Faculty and Student Technology Committee (FAST) that looks at the OIT organization with a view toward making recommendations for improvement. Erin Trochim, guest speaker at the last meeting, had spoken about the Graduate Student Conference taking place in September. The graduate student abstract deadline is coming up at the end of this month for that conference. Jon encourages the faculty to help their students to participate in this effort, as well as to be involved with it themselves. Flyers are at the back table with details. B. President-Elect's Report Cathy Cahill Cathy also thanked the Senate for voting to extend their terms. She is definitely looking for individuals to step up for president-elect next year. One of the primary things shes been working on the past few months with the executive leadership workshop and the Planning and Budget Committee, is the state of the budget and where we are going to be, given where we are in the legislative process at this time. The budget for the university is not looking good. We as faculty need to be prepared and willing to get our input into the process, helping identify what is good in our programs, what the deficiencies are, and how we can make them run more efficiently. Please share your ideas and suggestions for dealing with the budget difficulties with her, the Provost and the Chancellor. Theyre looking for ways to save money and still maintain the academic standards that we uphold as the faculty. IV Guest Speaker A. Mark Hamilton, UA President [President Hamiltons remarks were recorded, along with the rest of the Faculty Senate meeting. Contact Jayne Harvie at x7964 for instructions to access the recording.] Jon introduced President Mark Hamilton as todays guest speaker. The President talked about the conclusion of the UA presidential search, saying that he had met with his successor, Pat Gamble, who is anxious to take over this responsibility. Hamilton was not personally involved with the search, leaving that decision to the BOR since the position of president works for them. He remarked candidly about the security associated with the search, encouraging everyone that in this case, as well as the situation mentioned by Jon D. in his remarks, that good people survive bad process. He told Pat Gamble that it will be the greatest learning curve hell encounter, given the statewide scope of 16 campuses, and the scope of the University mission, not to mention the geographical scope being dealt with. The President remarked on the Academic Master Plan, thanking Provost Susan Henrichs for her work on it. Related to this effort on the plan, he believes that its absolutely necessary that we look ahead at what our expectations are of each of the major academic units. The system can not continue if its guided only by plans based on aspirations, as opposed to disciplined plans which are needed to remain an excellent institution within the bounds of its charge. He commended the Board of Regents for going after only one new facility rather than the laundry list approach. What was evident from the laundry list approach was that the priority of the BOR would be overlooked in favor of regional support. Thus, roughly 80% of new construction accomplished in his tenure has been at Anchorage, due to the political realities not because of the BORs priority or budget. Hes somewhat fearful that if the Regents recommendation does get passed, that it will go on to a general order bond. If that happens, it will be a remarkable challenge, given the political atmosphere were facing. With concerns at the national level that were going so far into debt, the probability that a new general order bond that says we take on six hundred million dollars of debt is very likely to crash and burn. Speaking about the future, President Hamilton believes the pipeline is a pipe dream. He wishes that he would be proven wrong on this, because his children and grandchildren are here and he plans to stay here. But, its a simple matter of supply and demand, and he provided figures and statistics to support it. 2035-2040 is when he believes it will be more realistic that supply and demand will support bringing North Slope oil to the market. In the meantime, he doesnt think well deal with a fiscal crisis. We may deal with some decisions based on fear, causing their own crisis. As there is more demand for oil down the road, oil will likely be $85 to $100 dollars a barrel in the future. What it means for us here at the university is that we plenty of time to adjust to this without panic. But, we need to start asking ourselves the difficult questions. He hopes the faculty is very involved in this, and it will take honesty and a tremendous depth of introspection. Does the university need three education schools, or three business schools? Should biology be out of one campus as the nursing program is? He then shared about an interesting thesis hes had for many years. Being convinced there something to the thesis, he even presented it to the Joint Chiefs of Staff of the U.S. military. The thesis is that the most likely organization of institutions follows, by one generation, the most popular childrens toy. He provided examples of building blocks, Legos, and transformers, relating them to the development of new and more complex organizational models of the day. The latest, transformers, use all (and only) the pieces available to become something new. He told the Joint Chiefs of Staff, from this example that we have to make one unit that can transform into the necessary instrument of utility, rather than building a new army for every war. About three years later he read the first business book on transformational organizations. In the future, there will be the spontaneous formation of teams that take on tasks without ever seeing or knowing one another except via the internet. Were still informed by the transformation analogy. We need to use all and only the pieces of the university to design the instrument of service and continuity for the future. He says all because he thinks the perfect solution is not to have to worry about getting rid of individuals in administration or faculty. Well use only and all the instruments that we have available to us its a worthy challenge. We have the remarkable luxury of time. There may be panic and knee jerk reactions, but lets not be the source of those reactions. Theres time to be thoughtful and contemplative about this and do things that are only different and not evil as we move forward. Folks, including the faculty, have been very kind dealing with him. Hes not an academic and has none of the contempt born of familiarity. He thinks the faculty is absolutely magnificent. He has gone to nearly 100 commencement exercises and he knows what faculty do -- they transform lives. Watching people go across the stage accomplishing something they didnt think they could do is all he has needed every year to be reenergized. He admires terrifically what the faculty do and how they do it. He described himself as an absolute freak for statistics and analysis, and loves the idea of informational-based decision making and so he wanted to leave them with the following facts. The university was founded in 1917, with its first graduate in 1921. But, half of all people getting degrees from the University of AV̳ (he admitted its actually 47%) got their degrees under his watch. Were still very new to our service for AV̳, and our influence on the state. He admires those who were here in the desert the 10 years with no funding increases at all who held the institution together. We have built a different university, its depth in this state and its level of service in this state are so increased and there will not be another time in the desert. Weve gone from 40% of AV̳s college bound students coming to this university to this fall, when close to 67% of AV̳ students will come here. Its going to be a wonderful time for faculty to continue their careers here. The university is here to stay and faculty have made the difference. Cecile L. asked how he sees UAF and UAA continuing into the future, given the element of competition. President Hamilton stated that his opinion is that competition absolutely has to end, and he will make the same statement to the UAA faculty next week. Lets be fabulous at what we are. If there are to be professional doctorates offered, lets make sure were not just picking any one we can to gain the prestige. Lets pick one that is of sufficient service to the state, and that were willing to pay for to achieve quality delivery. Faculty can agree to jointly offer Ph.D. programs, and a professional Ph.D. might be the way to start. He would like it to be the result of a continuum that says, for example, we have an excellent baccalaureate program in education and an excellent masters in education, and so its only appropriate that we move forward to offer an Ed.D. It should not be transparent aspiration for the purpose of prestige. Hes been disturbed by the very fact that the top facility building project at UAA is a sports arena. What about their engineering building or refurbishing their science building? Isnt the next program down there an Allied Health one? He cant believe that a sports arena is their top priority. Its aspiration that goes beyond the pale. It costs a lot of money to offer Ph.D.s, and there is no possibility that the state can financially support two universities to do it. The infrastructure is here at UAF it does not need duplication down there. How it will work out politically he doesnt know, but thats his long-held opinion. He again expressed his sincere admiration for the faculty and wished everyone the greatest fortune in their own lives and professionally as they continued their service to the state. He departed to a standing ovation by those present. V A. Chancellors Comments Brian Rogers The BOR meets next week in Dillingham. One item theyre reviewing is the Academic Master Plan. Theres also an issue coming to the BOR he wants the Senate to consider, which is guns on campus. A presentation will be given by a 2nd amendment group to the BOR. He wants faculty to address the issue and let the BOR know their views. Were fairly tolerant at UAF, having a rifle team and providing secure lock-up of student-owned firearms. But concealed carry of firearms is the specific issue being discussed. Theres an interesting clash of priorities on this issue, and faculty should weigh in on it as it concerns their classrooms. The BOR may consider changes in policy. As the legislature is moving into its last days on the budget, theyre more hopeful about certificates of participation regarding the Life Sciences facility in the budget process. Movement away from a bond issue will help the project become a reality this summer, and get it fully funded. The operating budget looks fairly challenging. Clearly, there will need to be some reallocation in the coming year and choices made on where to focus new investment and where to cut back. Hes been preparing some briefing papers for the new president on UAF-related issues. If there are any issues they want the president to be aware of, please email the Chancellors Office. Lastly, he commented on how President Hamilton used the term MAU, as major academic unit rather than the more common major administration unit Brien said we may see more use of the term the way the President used it. B. Provosts Remarks Susan Henrichs Susan looks forward to senate input on the Academic Master Plan. The plan represents many compromises made by the System Academic Council (SAC) that has put it together. There were extensive and usually constructive discussions during its formation. In giving her input, Susan asked the senate members to be specific and constructive to please give alternatives and suggestions, not just flat statements about something that isnt liked. As they go into an operating review to present detailed budget plans, theyll also give a detailed performance review. Related to performance, our graduation rates are not great. The six-year rate for graduation, including first-time freshman and associate and certificate degree seekers, is only 25% completion. Its not within about 50% of some of our peer institutions, which is not great. Mitigating that is were almost an open admission university. We only just recently tightened up the admissions standards. If we look at our retention, in the course of the first year and toward the end of the first year, we lose 37% of our incoming students if you count the associates degrees and certificates. Our freshmen retention isnt bad if you look at our peer institutions, but its still not great. But weve retained 63% of our first-time, full-time freshman. Another 13 % of these students are lost the next year. Years after that, (about 12 years out) we only lose 6 %. But, theyre graduating very, very slowly. What she would like to see us do as a university is to redouble our efforts to retain incoming students, and help those who are taking a long time to attain graduation. Cecile L. noted that in psychology which is a large major, students move in and out of universities more than they used to. They have had to redesign their curriculum and rearrange their program plans. She asked to what extent these numbers reflect students who attend through the military and who otherwise move around a lot. How realistic is it to have those students who start here, finish here? Susan responded that while we do see a lot of that, the numbers shes speaking about are a cohort model; the group of students looked at were those who started and stayed here, over a 12-year time frame). At the end of that 12-year period, we still had either graduated or still taking classes, over 45 % of those incoming freshman students. Theres a lot of hanging on and getting through the system very gradually. VI Governance Reports A. Staff Council Martin Klein Martin reminded all that Staff Appreciation Day is coming up on May 19. He mentioned the ongoing union organization efforts of non-represented staff by two different unions. Statewide Labor Relations has good info on their web site about both of them. Staff Council members were in Juneau in March and they spoke with several legislators. They were successful in conveying the message that we are one university not three. A leave share resolution was also passed by SC (identical to the one passed by the senate); and they will bring it up at Staff Alliance shortly. The Chancellor asked Jon D. and him to appoint folks to serve on the New Facility Naming Committee, and Martin will chair (in his Facilities Services role). He mentioned names of folks on the committee (Cathy Cahill, Maria Russell, Emily Drygus and Deb Horner). B. ASUAF Todd Vorisek No report was available. C. UAFT/UNAC No report available. Public Comment (as an item introduced to the agenda at the beginning of the meeting): Vice Provost Dana Thomas mentioned the Mandatory Placement policy that the senate had passed and that was approved, and that this will be a transitional year of implementing that new policy. Theyll work very hard not to impact students whove already taken placement tests this fall with the newer requirements. UAF has signed up for the voluntary system of accountability an agreement and process that was reached via the Association of Public and Land Grant Universities (which is the new name for NASULGC the National Association of State Universities and Land Grant Colleges). Under the Bush administration, Secretary Spelling (Education) pressed hard for an act like No Child Left Behind for universities. A lot of faculty and administrations across the country thought it would ease up after Bush left office, but this is not the case. The motivation for the continuing efforts on this national legislation is that the cost of higher education is growing faster than Health Care even, and so people want accountability. In response to this, a voluntary system of accountability was formed. He urges faculty to look at their site: http://www.voluntarysystem.org/ The site is paired with College Portrait, and taking part requires having a student survey. UAF is using the NSSE survey and has data posted at College Portrait. The other piece of this effort is that in two years they must implement an exam for incoming freshman and exiting seniors a sample of the whole (200 incoming freshmen, 100 exiting seniors). Three exams have been approved for this purpose. One is the CLA, the Collegiate Learning Assessment. The other two are written by ETS and ACT (MAPP and CAAP are their names). http://www.voluntarysystem.org/docs/cp/LearningOutcomesInfo.pdf At the next senate meeting, he wants to make a recommendation that we use one next year. Please look at these three tests and come prepared to share opinions and ask questions. Jane W. asked him where the sample numbers of 200 and 100 come from. Dana answered that it came from the people developing these tests. He got this from the workshop he attended recently. Theyre trying to reduce the margin of error so they can assess learning gained. BREAK occurred at 2:10 PM. NOTE: All referenced attachments are contained in the Agenda #166. VII New Business A. Motions to Amend the Faculty Senate Bylaws, submitted by the Faculty Affairs Committee (Attachments 166/1-166/4; 166/5-All Changes) Motion 161/1 was brought to the floor by Faculty Affairs Chair Jennifer Reynolds. Its purpose is to amend the Bylaws of the University of AV̳ Fairbanks Faculty Senate, Section 1, Article III: Membership, subsection B.4 (page 13). This amendment changes the way split appointments are handled in reapportionment calculations for representation on the Faculty Senate. Jennifer gave a comprehensive background of the bylaws changes which carried over from the March meeting. She talked at length describing how faculty numbers were apportioned between academic and research assignments for those with split appointments. Its been a very heavy workload to read every appointment letter to correctly account for split appointments. The Provosts Office did the laborious task last year and provided the data to Faculty Affairs. Currently, research units (GI, IARC, and IAB) are represented as a conglomerate unit. With the newer reapportionment figures, however, both the Geophysical Institute and the International Arctic Research Center are now large enough in numbers of faculty to each have two representatives on the Faculty Senate. This will go into effect next year. All of the IAB faculty also have teaching appointments at CNSM. If their faculty are all counted as research, then they qualify for their own representation, but CNSM would drop two seats. In addition to that effect, a new group of blended research faculty are created, which includes the museum, INE and other small units. Faculty Affairs supports split appointments being dropped for reapportionment purposes. They would be counted in their unit of their primary appointment. This would be the tenure-granting unit, where their rank is determined. There arent any faculty with split appointments who dont have part of their appointments in a unit that doesnt also grant tenure. Rainer N. asked about how they go about saying we want to do this as outlined in Motion 161/1 for subsection B.4 of the Faculty Senate bylaws. A motion was made to consider these apportionment changes in 161/1, and then a vote was taken. It was unanimously approved by the ayes (no nays and no abstentions). The two versions outlined in the motion were then discussed. Next, a vote was taken on Motion 161/1, version 1 of B.4, which received no ayes. A vote followed on Motion 161/1, version 2 of B.4 to count faculty by means of their tenure-granting unit for apportionment purposes. The ayes passed version 2 of Motion 161/1 unanimously. Motion 166/2 for bylaws subsection B.8 was then considered. This amendment addresses the frequency of reapportionment for the purpose of Faculty Senate representation. Currently, the bylaws state that its done every two years or upon a two-thirds vote of the senate. In practice, though, this is not happening. This motion recommends that reapportionment coincide with the accreditation review year, every seven years, when the Provosts Office is already gathering the necessary data in the accreditation process. The motion was called to question and seconded. A vote was taken and the motion was unanimously passed, with no nays and no abstentions. Motion 166/3 on bylaws subsection C.1 was considered next, having to do with elections of senators in the research units. Currently, the bylaws state all of the elections in the research units are coordinated out of the Faculty Senate office. This procedure worked when the units were very small in numbers and were treated as a conglomerate unit; but, now theyve grown and this is no longer practical. This motion transfers the conducting of elections back to the larger research units that will have their own representation on the senate. The motion was called to question and seconded. A vote was taken, and the ayes passed it unanimously, with no nays and no abstentions. Motion 166/4 on bylaws subsection C.4 was then considered. In reference to election of representatives to the Faculty Senate, this amendment addresses the voting procedure for faculty with split appointments (in multiple units). This motion presented two versions for discussion, and the version selected must be in alignment with the versions of Motion 161/1 which addressed reapportionment. Version 1 received no votes. Version 2 was adopted so that faculty will vote either in their tenure-granting unit (if tenure-track), or in the unit of their primary appointment (faculty with research appointments). The motion (version 2) was called to question and the vote taken. The ayes passed it unanimously. B. Motion to Reaffirm ANLC/ANLP Unit Criteria, submitted by the Unit Criteria Committee (Attachment 166/6) Brenda K. brought this to the floor. The committee thought these criteria looked good and only minor changes were requested. Larry R. called it to question and it was seconded. The vote was taken, and the ayes passed the motion unanimously. C. Motion to Approve an AAS degree in Drafting Technology, submitted by the Curricular Affairs Committee (Attachment 166/7) Ken A. brought the motion to floor. Some modifications were made; after much discussion in committee, particularly regarding the math requirement and resource requirements. Rainer N. called it to question and Jane W. seconded. The motion passed by majority; with one abstention; and no nays. D. Motion to Approve a Minor in Mining Engineering, submitted by the Curricular Affairs Committee (Attachment 166/8) Ken brought the motion to the floor and described it. It had unanimous approval in the committee. Rainer mentioned there is no cost involved, and called it to question which was seconded. The motion passed unanimously. E. Motion to amend the UAF "Policies and Regulations for the Appointment and Evaluation of Faculty" (Attachment 166/9) Jennifer R. described the background of this motion and the situations creating a need for a promotion procedure for faculty who are not represented. These faculty are usually supervising other faculty and filling an administrative role, but still have 49% academic duties. Faculty Affairs held three meetings of extensive discussion on this topic. They recommend a similar promotion procedure as that for represented faculty. These non-represented faculty should still have 49% faculty duties in their workload in addition to their administrative role. They talked about issues of unit peer committee representation. A special peer committee will be appointed for these faculty, and a dean or director outside their academic unit will select the faculty. Otherwise, the procedure is just like that for a regular faculty. The criteria for evaluation will be the same as for those with 51% academic duties. Who is on the unit peer committee and how that committee is appointed was addressed to avoid conflicts of interest. The motion was called to question and seconded. A vote was taken and the motion was passed unanimously. F. Motion of Confirmation for Outstanding Senator of the Year Award, submitted by the OSYA Selection Committee (Attachment 166/10) Cathy spoke to the motion as chair of the selection committee. Both Jennifer Reynolds and Anne Christie were nominated. The committee felt that both were deserving of recognition for taking on the herculean task of addressing reapportionment issues. Resounding ayes confirmed the motion. (One abstention from Jennifer.) VIII Announcements A. Chancellors Advisory Committee for the Naming of Campus Facilities Cathy C. will fill this role on behalf of the senate. and this may be a traditional role for the president-elect in the future. B. Promotion & Tenure Workshop on April 23, 2010 (Handout) Jon announced the workshop. Cathy encouraged everyone to remind others in their units, also. IX Discussion Items A. Academic Master Plan Susan Henrichs, Jon Dehn (Handout) Available online at: http://www.uaf.edu/uafgov/faculty/09-10_senate_meetings/index.html#166 Rainer suggested that in light of President Hamiltons estimate of the viability of a gas pipeline, that rewording might be in order for page 16, the second paragraph. Rainer said as a potential alternative, some discussion of apparent or real competition or dichotomy between nonrenewable and renewable resource extraction; referring, of course, to the Pebble controversy. Jon raised some of the comments hes heard. The vision statement, while good, is lean. More background and support is needed for what sorts of needs we have in the state. Statements such as meeting students needs and the needs of the state need statistics and figures to back them up. How many students stay in state and with what programs? Under new and augmented programs; the wording makes it appear that different means will be used for evaluating various programs. For example, education programs will not be approved without statewide planning groups being involved; whereas for engineering programs it only mentions that program deans agree. It looked like the criteria were different when theyre actually not. Ken A. noted that on page number 8, at the fourth bold dot down, it states, For instructional programs, student demand for the program exists proportionate to the resources needed to offer it. He was concerned that it could be used to throw new resources to Anchorage because of the population base of Anchorage. The School of Management could have a hard time competing for new programs in this case. If you put UAF against UAA in light of student demand numbers, Anchorage would win. This could really impact distance campuses when justifying instructional programs. Programs are needed to train people for jobs in high demand in an area, but may not necessarily be economical to offer at an area. Susan responded that the idea was that the demand would be proportionate to the resources, so that if you were serving fewer students, say 50, you wouldnt need all the resources that you would need if you were serving 100 students. Its problematic for a program such as Dental Hygiene, which is quite expensive and can only have six students admitted per year compared to the expenses of offering it; vs. a low program startup cost for something like History. Shell look carefully at how its been presented. The intent is that student demand would be just one criteria among others to be looked at, its one part of the puzzle. You must also consider state needs and a variety of other factors before making a decision one way or the other. Jon D. emphasized that its important to look over the master plan its the foundation upon which other plans will be built. He spoke to some of the things affecting development of new programs that are contained in the plan. One must go to the BOR to pre-approve developing a new Ph.D. program, for example. If this requirement is approved, it will substantially affect how new programs are developed. Its not meant to inhibit program development, but rather to keep programs from investing time and efforts on something that will not have much chance of success. It needs to be carefully and clearly worded, however. Cecile L. asked whether theres sense of competition among the faculty about developing Ph.D. programs, or if that is occurring at the administrative level. Jon responded that the majority of faculty realize developing a Ph.D. program is no trivial undertaking. While some at UAA may want to deliver Ph.D. programs, theyre not accredited to do so. The matter was an administrative point of contention, not a faculty one. B. Peer Observation Form Josef Glowa (Attachment 166/11) Forms are posted online at: http://www.uaf.edu/uafgov/faculty/09-10_senate_meetings/index.html#166 Jon shared about some of the discussion that took place in Administrative Committee. Its not a form thats required in any way, nor one that would likely be included in ones promotion and tenure file. It was developed for use among peers, and it can also be used as a self-observation form. Its useful to read over during the semester, especially when offering a new class. He really likes it and its a useful form in many ways. C. Update on Follett Bookstore Ken Abramowicz, Jane Weber Ken A. shared about the proposal by Follett to bring books back to the campus. The UAF Bookstore also has one. Ken and Jane W. are on the bookstore committee and evaluated the proposals. Folletts was more a proposal to make a contract, and he and Jane advised against it, unless Follett extended the UAF Bookstore with its current employees. But the decision is at the Chancellors Cabinet level. There are lots of ideas under discussion, and theyre still hoping for a full-fledged bookstore on campus. Rainer asked if anything will happen in the next couple of months. To Kens knowledge, no decision has been made yet by Chancellors Cabinet. Rainer noted that potentially decisions could be made during the summer when faculty arent around. Jon mentioned hes been very vocal to the Chancellor and Provost about the need for a physical bookstore at this university. He promises the Administrative Committee will watch it closely over the summer. Ken commented that it came up loud and clear during their committee meetings that the administration doesnt think theres any problem. As time goes by, people resolve problems in other ways and the faculty and students do the best they can. He doesnt want the administration to think the problem has gone away and encourages faculty and students to be vocal about any problems with books to the administration. Robert Holden reiterated that there has been no resolution to the issues which have been brought up. They are working towards bringing books back to campus, no matter what. Jon asked for any numbers on how it went this semester. Robert agreed that it was quiet this semester. He, too, asked for people to make problems known. Only a limited number of people took advantage of the books brought on campus, but, the effort helped students taking core classes and those testing into classes. Robert said that Loly Tilly Commons would be an ideal space as a bookstore. D. Update on the Core/LEAP discussions Ken said there will be a meeting next Monday and theyll go line by line on the Core objectives. They will then invite faculty comments. Next year theyll plan to discuss how to implement the core objectives into courses. Kens hope is that they complete objectives so they can get into discussion on courses next year. X Committee Reports Jon recommended reviewing minutes, and reminded folks about the annual reports due at the next meeting. NOTE: All referenced attachments are contained in the Agenda #166. A. Curricular Affairs Falk Huettmann, Ken Abramowicz (Attachment 166/12) B. Faculty Affairs Jennifer Reynolds (Attachment 166/13) C. Unit Criteria Brenda Konar (Attachment 166/14) D. Committee on the Status of Women Jane Weber, Alex Fitts (Attachment 166/15 E. Core Review Latrice Laughlin F. Curriculum Review Rainer Newberry G. Faculty Appeals & Oversight Charlie Sparks H Faculty Development, Assessment & Improvement Josef Glowa (Attachment 166/16) I. Graduate Academic & Advisory Committee Rajive Ganguli J. Student Academic Development & Achievement Cindy Hardy K. Ad Hoc Committee: Advisory Research Committee Roger Hansen XI Members' Comments/Questions Tim Stickel mentioned Fairbanks registration opened today; and the new Banner implementation impacted servers for registration. OIT worked on it and so far things are again working great. Commencement is on May 16; and currently there are 889 graduation applications and theyve completed 603 degree audits to date, with more to be done by mid-April. Jon mentioned they went to yellow on Mt. Redoubt this morning, so be aware of that if traveling. XII Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 3:17 PM.     PAGE  PAGE 1 #&'(,057=>NThij    / 2 A B C _ ǿzoz^ZMh &hCJOJQJha h &haCJOJQJmHsHhKh>*CJOJQJh &haCJOJQJh &ha>*CJOJQJhaOJQJh'hG CJOJQJaJhG 5>*OJQJh$OJQJhOJQJhg OJQJh.ht5>*OJQJhOJQJhtOJQJh.htOJQJhG OJQJ(>Tij   2 B dh$Ifgd:]$a$gdt$a$bB C S _ t dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:]gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ_ s t u   $ & ' 5 @ B C Q ` a o µvlblvlXha?CJOJQJhO;CJOJQJh]CJOJQJh &h]CJOJQJha?hO;>*CJOJQJha?ha?>*CJOJQJh &hO;CJh &hO;CJOJQJh &h)'CJmHsHh &h)'CJOJQJ h &h)'CJOJQJmHsHh &hCJh &hCJOJQJhCJOJQJ"t u dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:]gkdv$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ t dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd5gkdb$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:]gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:]gkdN$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ  % & t dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgd:]gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ& ' 5 A B t dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgd:]gkd:$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJB C a p q dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd:]gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJo q r ~     / 7 9 : I Q R b d e o p { } ~ 꿲ӲӇӇh &ha?CJh &h\CJh\>*CJOJQJhZh\>*CJOJQJh &h\CJOJQJh\CJOJQJh]CJOJQJh &ha?CJOJQJha?CJOJQJh &hO;CJh &hO;CJOJQJ5q r ~ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5gkd&$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$IfgdB dh$Ifgd5gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ   t dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk> dh$IfgdBgkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ  $ 8 9 t dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk> dh$IfgdBgkdt$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ9 : R c d t dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk> dh$IfgdBgkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJd e p | } t dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk> dh$IfgdBgkd`$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ} ~ t dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk> dh$IfgdBgkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk>gkdL$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ dh$Ifgdf dh$Ifgdk>gkd$$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk>gkd8 $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ   t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd5 dh$Ifgdk>gkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ  " % & 8 9 L M _ b c q t u  @ A B P Q ӳ{{skhwOJQJhtOJQJhH(OJQJhbEOJQJh|OJQJha+OJQJh;x8OJQJhBxFOJQJhOJQJhG OJQJhZha?>*CJOJQJh :CJOJQJh &ha?CJha?CJOJQJh &ha?CJOJQJh &ha?CJmHsH( # $ % t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd` dh$Ifgdk>gkd$ $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ% & 6 7 8 t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd` dh$Ifgdk>gkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ8 9 J K L t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd` dh$Ifgdk>gkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJL M ` a b t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd` dh$IfgdBgkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJb c r s t t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd5 dh$IfgdBgkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJt u t dh$Ifgd:] dh$Ifgd5 dh$IfgdBgkdr $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ    bgdBxF gdtgkd $$IflF t"`   "    44 layt3rJ  #%&'RSUY`dl:Kd~QS1ʷwwowowh( OJQJh>6OJQJhN&OJQJhH(OJQJhOJQJhCOJQJhzIOJQJhG OJQJh9>OJQJh6 h9>OJQJh6 OJQJhZqOJQJh-hBxFOJQJh\hBxFOJQJhBxFOJQJhtOJQJhG OJQJ+ $&'TU01Z[`aUV |gd,E pgd6 pgdZq1Bty  !.3VWY`| *1>H  2>lmнȭhQ+OJQJhQCOJQJhX )OJQJhD}*OJQJhpOJQJh>(OJQJh>(h>(OJQJhOJQJhMUOJQJh&OJQJhAyOJQJh.2)OJQJh>6OJQJhH(OJQJ4_alt*+Yfi !&23<@FPSSUVhȸనਰxhBxFOJQJh<-OJQJh;{OJQJh*DOJQJh$qOJQJhCOJQJh%OJQJhk_OJQJhYOJQJh}`OJQJh$OJQJhQ+OJQJhQCOJQJh}OJQJhvOJQJhG OJQJhDOOJQJ/VWhi45^_y!z!:#;#%%p,q,h.i.2288 bgdBxFgdBxFhijl58DNfw{&)256:E]x`ͽŽյյխյյŵյյխեխՕՕՕՕhzOJQJh"+OJQJh9OJQJh- OJQJh_|OJQJhqdOJQJh$OJQJh<-OJQJhv_OJQJh0OJQJh.hBxFOJQJhBxFOJQJht+aOJQJ:$\]^_}$%Vi2hqy&*+-4KLfps|}~ਠȨȠȐȨhPOJQJh"OJQJh#lOJQJhOJQJhb#aOJQJh2OJQJh[+OJQJh_eOJQJhOJQJhxOJQJh(OJQJhBxFOJQJhzOJQJhv_OJQJ8   ' , - J V b !(!7!?!F!N!Z!_!z!!!!! " "Q"R"{"""""""7#9#;#e######నhz2UOJQJh0DOJQJhidOJQJhIxOJQJh=OJQJh^OJQJhjOJQJhb#aOJQJhj]OJQJh3OJQJhPOJQJhpvOJQJh(OJQJhPOJQJh#lOJQJ5###### $$$$/$7$L$c$o$y$$$$$$$$$$$$% %,%B%C%P%]%%%%%%%& &&#&$&%&*&:&D&L&S&T&W&\&f&i&&&&&&&&&hw7OJQJhsOJQJh %OJQJh-kOJQJh| OJQJhmOJQJhpvOJQJhHOJQJhb#aOJQJhOJQJhz2UOJQJhidOJQJ?&&'4'B'C'D'J''''''''((R(((((((() )))S)T)v)))))**F*`***********L+f+i++и踰hOJQJhXJOJQJh+ OJQJhZOJQJhzKOJQJhVbPOJQJh_OJQJhb#aOJQJhsOJQJh87OJQJhUOJQJhmOJQJhidOJQJhw7OJQJ5++++++o,p,v,,,,,!-0->------..3.@.h.i........./!/$/A/B/F/p////ਠxxph,hOJQJhb2OJQJhUOJQJhjcOJQJh~OJQJhbOJQJh_OJQJhX`DOJQJhdOJQJhw7OJQJhOJQJhUOJQJhidOJQJhXJOJQJh}JOJQJhOJQJhmOJQJh OJQJ,///00 00"0506090;0<0t0x0z0{00000000!1&1=1q1111111122 22'232S2T2z222222$3@3K3M3N3hzOJQJhAOJQJh OJQJhX`DOJQJh1EOJQJhCOJQJh3OJQJh/OJQJhUOJQJhjcOJQJh,hOJQJhf8OJQJh`OJQJh~OJQJhb2OJQJ5N3]333J4x4y4z4~44444444444455%5W5r5555555555555 66 6,6<6K6T6U6`6i6p6u6v6z6ȠȨhzOJQJh.ROJQJhAOJQJhOOJQJh^OJQJh.OJQJhMOJQJh<OJQJhxOJQJhROJQJh ~OJQJhOOJQJhjOJQJh OJQJh!OJQJhOJQJ2z6666666666 7"7-7v7~77777777788878I8L8w8|8888888r9s9999999yhDOOJQJhG OJQJhwiHh\&B*OJQJphhKLOJQJh0POJQJhQPOJQJhOJQJhbOJQJhEIOJQJh:1&OJQJhzOJQJh+_OJQJh!OJQJhAOJQJh.ROJQJh OJQJ,899999<<::::::::::::::;!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;<s<u<<<<<<=C=P=r=|====)>譥Ǵϴϴϴ4ϴ%ϴ,ϴ5ϴϴ*ϴ%ʸϴ%ϴʸϴϴ@ϴ7)>0>4>>>>>>?:?=???@@*մAABB1OJQJh5OJQJh4OJQJ+)D>DYEaEkElEzEEEEEEEF FDFbFuFFFFFFFFFF4G5G?GdGGGGGHH#H_H~HHHI)J*JrJsJ(K)KKKgLhLoMpMMMMMMMMMM N!N[O\ORRR&T 8gdMMMMMMMMMMMMMMN!N.N9NHN\N}NNNOZO\OwOOOOOOOOP!PjPkPtPxP|PPPPPPPPPPPPP𽵽hP|OJQJhgOJQJhOOJQJhoo9OJQJh9DOJQJh,**OJQJh;OJQJhbOJQJhOJQJh.hOJQJhBxFOJQJheOJQJh`OJQJh@<OJQJ4PQ*Q2QSQtQwQ|QQQQQQQQR RRR0RFRGRPR]RjRmRtRRRRRRRR S+S.SiSsSSSSSSSSSSSTTT%T'TnTxTyTTTTTииhy6fOJQJhOJQJhYOJQJ hYhYhYOJQJh OJQJhgOJQJh;,OJQJhoo9OJQJhP|OJQJh`OJQJh4qOJQJhE$OJQJ<&T'TUUUUVVVVOJQJhEOJQJhEOJQJh`OJQJ hhhgOJQJhOJQJhy6fOJQJh OJQJ)=WAWMWOWWWdAdLdMdNdOdPdWd`djdsdddeeJebeyee:fpffffg g8g9ggggfhhhhhi:i_iaiиЬ{sh dOJQJhnOJQJh$OJQJh$OJQJaJh)AyOJQJaJh)Ayh)AyOJQJaJh)AyCJOJQJaJh9OJQJhNv$OJQJh'4OJQJh)AyOJQJhN6OJQJhoOJQJh~xOJQJh*oOJQJh 3OJQJ,aiiiiiii5j6jnMnZn[ndnen~nnnnnnnnn?oBooooop$pCpDpOpppppppppp&q'qLqнŵ𽭽}}}haOJQJhqOJQJhc]OJQJh@OJQJh~AOJQJhTD8OJQJhDOJQJhkOJQJh9wxOJQJhmKhBxFOJQJhBxFOJQJhbOJQJh)OJQJh7OJQJh @OJQJh7$OJQJ/Lq^qqqqqqqqrr4rDrGrKrLrrrrrrrrsss#sXsYscssssssss]t_tittttzrh- OJQJh)OJQJhOJQJhQoOJQJh]eOJQJh3d hBxFOJQJh1uOJQJhp+hBxFOJQJhBxFOJQJh wOJQJhW<OJQJhiPiOJQJhqOJQJh)OJQJh#OJQJhaOJQJhOAOJQJ)ttttttuIuJuPuSuuuuuuuv v v%vgv}v~vvvww[w]wwwwwwwwxxx(x)x1xBxŽ͚͢Ňwooh|;OJQJh`OJQJh\WOJQJhKh}OJQJh_OJQJhQOJQJhF\h}OJQJh\WOJQJhZ OJQJh sOJQJh}OJQJh}OJQJha(OJQJhM0tOJQJhhQoOJQJh)OJQJhmOJQJ+u v vhviv}v~vvvwwxxyyl{m{ 8bgd <@ 8bgd z1$ 8ba$gd} 8bgd} pgd} 8pgd 8gd}Bx`xxxxxxxxxxxyyyy y>yUy\ydyeypyty}yyyyy3z=zzzzzzzzzzz{{#{'{4{8{^{g{l{t{{{{.|/|0|2|B||||||ظظనh$rh$rOJQJh$rOJQJhsOJQJhAT OJQJh$Q7OJQJh~OJQJhc]OJQJhrOJQJh8OJQJh_OJQJh|;OJQJh`OJQJ>|||||}_}{}}}}}}}}}}}~'~F~\~l~y~}~~~~ABPWv13G_pπ$ظذذȰبذhgOJQJhfzOJQJh[jOJQJhNHOJQJh*@OJQJhkOJQJhibOJQJhmzfOJQJhDVOJQJh'OJQJh "OJQJhsOJQJh$rOJQJ<$d?@ABZ0ER]„ĄńƄDŽ҄(;<=>ޅ谨蝕whxOJQJhKh}OJQJhxhh OJQJh}OJQJhKh_OJQJhh OJQJhyOJQJh_OJQJhP(OJQJh? OJQJhOJQJhxOJQJh{[ OJQJhgOJQJh%OJQJh*@OJQJ.=>z߅Ӈԇ҉Ӊ89stߐ 8pgd 8bgdh 8bgd}$ 8ba$gd} 8bgd <@64Z]ԇׇڇ$EIˆ-/gщӉȊ0CF[nŋ2轵譥蕍}}umumumuhLlOJQJh8OJQJh[OJQJhbOJQJhAOJQJhHOJQJhOJQJh6OJQJh{}OJQJhK!MOJQJhf{}OJQJh}OJQJhKh <@OJQJh <@OJQJh OJQJhOJQJhxOJQJhh OJQJ*237]Ό $(789?Rfist{Ս-MRX.8Ccrst~Ώ֏:Q[t|谨hXOJQJh8-OJQJh}OJQJhlIrOJQJh.%OJQJhtOJQJhbOJQJh<OJQJh5)OJQJhOJQJh8OJQJhLlOJQJ=|ސ],?cuؒ1c“ғ?@ABabemн赽誽赟wowowh`DOJQJhtZwOJQJhaZOJQJhOJQJhDOJQJh*OJQJhMh}OJQJhCh}OJQJh}OJQJhwDh}OJQJh<OJQJhOJQJhmOJQJhp2OJQJh}OJQJh8-OJQJhL5OJQJ+ߐۑ-cْ2qÓ@Aa 8pgd} 8Z]Zgd} 8gd} gd< 8pgdab!"ƕǕ()*;<bdeghjkmnwxyh]hgds*B*phe@ HTML Preformatted7 2( Px 4 #\'*.25@9B*CJOJQJ^Jph4@4 Header  !N!N  Char Char2CJOJQJ_HmH sH tH uH2H  Balloon TextCJOJQJ^JaJbOBb WDefault 7$8$H$-B*CJOJQJ^J_HaJmH phsH tH 8OQ8 Evapple-style-span4 @b4 sTij2BCS_tu%&'5ABCapqr~$89:Rcdep|}~  #$%&6789JKLM`abcrstu $&'TU0 1 Z [   ` a UVWhi45^_yz:;p$q$h&i&**001111144<7=788D8E8:: < < > >>>AAABB)B*BrBsB(C)CCCgDhDoEpEEEEEEEEEE F!F[G\GJJJ&L'LMMMMNNNN}}}ҁӁ89ه߈ۉ-ي2Ë!"ƍǍ()*;<bdeghjkmnwxy0000000000000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000@0H00@0H00@0H00@0H00@0@0@0@0@0@0H00,ABCapqr~89:cdep|}~  #$%&789KLMU0 1 Z [   h&i&**0AABB)B*BrBsB(C!F[G\GJJJ&L'LMMMUU1W2WYYYN\O\P\^^^ab5b6b*c+c,crcccdddeMeNe.f/f0fffhhjjkfkkklllmmImJmmm n nhnin}n~nnnooppqqlsmsy y{{=}>}z}}}00M00 00 00 00 00 0000 00 00 000 0 0 0 0 0 \iM0000'00000000000000@0 0000@0 00 0000@0 0000 0 00 0#0 0 00 0@0 0 000@`281  @0 00tM @0X# @0X# 0 0 @0X# 000 000 000 00 @0'() 00M@0'()*8 0000PM00@ 0:0;0:00:0000?00?0000J0D0E|J0D00J0D000I0 JnB0I0 0I00I00I00I00I00I00I00I0JnB0I00I00I000N00X00X000\000]0 ^mM0]00]00]00]00]00]00]00]00]00000H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0+H0k0*H0k0)0k00k0 0k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k00k000k0000000000H0SH0H00 $$$'_ o 1h#&+/N3z69)>)DIMPT=W^&caiYmLqtBx|$2|zLPYgoqrtuvwxyz{|~B t & B q  9 d } % 8 L b t V8)J&T]muߐaMOQRSTUVWXZ[\]^_`abcdefhijklmnps}N  '!!8@0(  B S  ?-/://T//dY////T/ /!/"/T#/$/%/&/T'/(/)/*/T+/,/-/./T//0/1/ 2/T 3/ 4/ 5/ 6/T 7/ 8/ 9/ :/T ;/ </ =/ >/T ?/ @/ A/ B/T TTY9 9 ))ss'''(()))GCGCXPXPfPSSSSSrttttttCuCuxx      !"$#%&'()*+,X__A A 11||$'''"("()))MCMCbPPPSSSSS{ttttttLuLu  !"$#%&'()*+,=-*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceName=+*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceType9,*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsState8**urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCityB!*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region د&-,+*,,*,*,*,!,,+-,,,*+,-,---+*,*,+-*,,*+,-ubbddeeghjkmnubbddeeghjkmn>To A BEELM=OPOaa f1flllm_Ab*<bbddeeghjkmnbbddeeghjkmnMnnZ-^< n7#AkGi8U, ?™" PA4,|"<9:JA($WVS{'`ĀM'2vu)g|/x.!+1ȰD9U^F=iTD:hK򜲂,;^܎#a3Ca*0fD' j>t`E$x0Ez>^`o(.^`. L ^ `L.  ^ `.xx^x`.HLH^H`L.^`.^`.L^`L.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hH0^`0o(.^`. L ^ `L.  ^ `.xx^x`.HLH^H`L.^`.^`.L^`L.80^8`0o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hHh ^`hH.h^`OJQJo(hHh pLp^p`LhH.h @ @ ^@ `hH.h ^`hH.h L^`LhH.h ^`hH.h ^`hH.h PLP^P`LhH.0^`0o(.^`. L ^ `L.  ^ `.xx^x`.HLH^H`L.^`.^`.L^`L.0^`0o(.^`. L ^ `L.  ^ `.xx^x`.HLH^H`L.^`.^`.L^`L.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hH^`^Jo()^`^J.pL^p`L^J.@ ^@ `^J.^`^J.L^`L^J.^`^J.^`^J.PL^P`L^J.hhh^h`OJQJo(hHh88^8`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh  ^ `OJQJo(hHh  ^ `OJQJ^Jo(hHohxx^x`OJQJo(hHhHH^H`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh pLp^p`LhH.h @ @ ^@ `hH.h ^`hH.h L^`LhH.h ^`hH.h ^`hH.h PLP^P`LhH.^`o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L.8^8`o(. ^`hH.  L^ `LhH.  ^ `hH. x^x`hH. HL^H`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hH^`CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo(pp^p`CJOJQJo(@ @ ^@ `CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo(^`CJOJQJo(PP^P`CJOJQJo(h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hH^`o(.) ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.h88^8`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh  ^ `OJQJo(hHh  ^ `OJQJo(hHhxx^x`OJQJ^Jo(hHohHH^H`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hH0^`0o(.^`. L ^ `L.  ^ `.xx^x`.HLH^H`L.^`.^`.L^`L.h88^8`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh  L ^ `LhH.h   ^ `hH.h xx^x`hH.h HLH^H`LhH.h ^`hH.h ^`hH.h L^`LhH.:E$xkGA($vu)D9i8CaU, nn7#a4S{'/|"ZtMnhK0ETiTD-^!+1S,;^M'' j" *0f^F=                          w%H!OBOLW,k9z o L)[+.V<ce}`n/!*/YIJPmn~=fY$<Ukxz|+f6;GIewfzT +B4q5>@@LYJa&msM|*Dou5 _&1G]b  w   8 * ? ? ^ h | g  + L IT W {[ Ar z {    - 1 v> F G P AT U ` m x | M R 1 3 4> G Oh v - 3 : O kT k o jz ;{ (  (=QPsQp\[g&9ACjn{&d)AX`hjN p26]b3mC"Y%IMENR]/g\ w=O;Vnr N(_09w:==@|XXZIu?07=@?EINX^ #x'LLTeZz'Wx{"r'1V=M?Xw_lmx$%H1>8AoACQDEPQ]gw"}  "%;l>MNYu Xgm(<-eCks  f6(;*5@Ww?C abgq |0@>DP ^VpvO'**;~R+  K SD o #!{ !;!C!]!_!5c!v!" "$"5"G8"?""J"P"!c" #1#DI#dW#a#q|#0$$$#$1$>3$7$E$i$Nv$|$%% %%.%3%og%3o%8|% $&H.&:1&A7&N&l&q&Iv&(y&l '')'F*'.'j3'?'6F'P'Z'Mh'( (H(a(t({(X )z))s).2)4)5)5)8)^)_)5|)* *,**D5*D*9[*e*D}*a+d++vT+V+ ^+z+~+<,,',-,F,K,j,io,&-p%-/7-;-<-A-_-a-h-.G .4.;.L.qs.{.s|..z&/$,/s/;a/kw/" 00-0O0_0im0Tt0x0|0111:1B1ZJ1cS1Y1~q1 z1{1222$2V*2-212@2@2A2*P2U2,f2 33'33!3R%3)3x3Xx34`4z4D44/H4=I4Y4 5 555!5,5L5lT5>6)6$86=6QO6"X6bb6Vj6n63787$Q7pR7+o7?88S8)(8m18TD8T8ZV8;x8`y8mU9Ha9oo9: :::&:}(:k>:5B:DK:[:I_:c:9j:j: o:u:;;;:;?;O;[;!e;h;|;g< <<<%<)<+<x.<N<W<+v<{< ==.=*=J=u=q0>6>S>f>k>9>M?*?.?#4?K?=N?a?cm? @+@ <@8C@H@Q@^@o@j~@AZAGA(AYCAXMANAOAa]AGB(B_BEBzBCC,C/C7C+8CACQC[C\C`CsC\wCD0DMDQRDRZDX`D`DiDhnDEEaE ETEEE,E1E1EINEbEeE~EiFF(FM/F;WFeFBxF GG?G GB!G!G%bJhJsjJjJ3rJwuJyzJ}J KK/K>ܰ>%󱹳!-#*6b-Dbibkblbnbwb~bh/c;cOcQcRc~YcZc\cdc8d?d@dGAddd@ud+zddI e e$e$,e6e\?eQe([e^e_eDfezefffy6fjfmzfzfgg"g_+g[7gRgegkgmghh&h,hi NiiPiRiei^iiui[jQj@njkk"k&kY+k-k-k/k>kek>eklkrk8{kAlOFlLlm@"mJ1mEmm n;n7n$EnvSnoQo,Vopo=wozolpk p.pp:p:p;pHpVp3rpiq$q`'qFux9wx~xc y&y)AyAyUyXyayDpyxyzyzzzzzq3z?zGzKzLzJOz oz7{{\{${*{>S!o<|F?|P|_|} }`}`}d}p}Ps}u}w}{}f{} ~ ~"~z&~*~X'E@NS+[^wy}O#/2DfJR:WZi} -|I]$jslmm>(12RAGHKLXRTIWiy}d-D>G~JOyS]#lY*t !?"#"5T5JJYtu}D $\&&(249TMV$rys9US^n!ucv^|2,FJYg{ b&'BDL=no)F, 8b9mim~t=b8`9b}} ;,0I1wRUa[gm,!/1Wp's7KXLkN.Rb" k69BH`biooU!l',9GqIOr^iao J%&y9%3GfNhPCZQjt.7$MOPgkn pr}!+> %5*=TCcv"01=lS^c~T/4y?@aT[y38HLZ$dWhsjneSG9vT{5}0rUh37dZux~VI 3#iFUp{-V[m8 +.4EyP]TY]gKr*Neu|{}t,#Y!ps"CqGT[j]|]^lImJ$&3:oCXfy|EV-9CD)FTx#.Uhtx C }.0g9>jtz 8<ExIJu# K*PuWt{ x7KkRST[ens}k<\"1-9t:~h"jn/u&x++a  (7?R@2W_do,o 9"/+0IMKK_N i 3,55Z\#,>6:ZdouZ ),-,JX \_bT Rq :_0eQl nP~5:$wLsO\wO"?HIKINPlxX1=)*=./JN?+MASY'(Z3K^v_bivAv#&)-7=>@\mps}/4$9mwyZE:b224J+RWdZp]8:E J\P\\d^Hi;{{>"+$p0BYQjcij^~ k.w7N|Q*YcxgtJu; a,[^hwZ"/3CGvJLT Y`eVnum-%&EWZ\^cwkxCq`} %l*D5wVDop"Q+J,A/\id]evz ""\>OTQXRcXc{]# IMhln "+JLQ\hnqf 8}ACcck4m.n4qh~8-@BiEO^v689;$E'\mv, '1(5+./zKQy]{aQjnizn{ : s "=mIMUlXY__a}n~N"3?Wcwwh(-9<?L/-0*@Q$Y sWp':~A]apx(DGW`ax %((l4?9D)F+q!'+0=Vastu"+f8eH)TVei|X#4:DTU8hW||X0XT}_gx"!Z7)R Y`bZqe j=@c45@fBKMc]zQ}7D l$1'5/J[*]q^toqm %,< dlm q(@<=EIJkMaMh'(aJ_p_7| ~ ""'U5BEF?Nam'#78TB%mJoqry$K%e1n=BzK.YW]~+9BF*MwXaZO^}| !$$u,[]mznu|1!`[n@o 1'4+%)-.d"ehiOprrbtp26 L5(7_W8gag-mo~Z 5{K`X @XPr{;~jP(>2:z=HfT` dzqu=S5N68Ec|d#g[{|zZ'+5p@TV`x#"I(8`fgooXz % &)+"5<>UO]?^^8>OABDmF  &.S223EFZuh z;9@`D^jk@lzU2HM (37CX\gN < .mi4"=EF"$'G17SY5\_d}pL$-<4M=WE\ETjz3\ [N"3$,>sI`qdhWI(9~Mrb)8:t\ffh2BCS_tu%&'5ABCapqr~$89:Rcdep|}~  #$%&6789JKLM`abcrstu@8 @Unknown Gz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial3z TimesA GenevaArial?5 : Courier New5& zaTahoma7&{ @Calibri;Wingdings"1hz:"&@"yH@"yH!4d$ 2qHX ?c]2MINUTESfnjbhfnjbh                         Oh+'0  4 @ L Xdlt|MINUTESfnjbh Normal.dotfnjbh392Microsoft Office Word@@/_@&@$ćB@"y՜.+,0 hp  University of AV̳H' MINUTES Title  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~     #Root Entry FB%Data 1TableWordDocument.:SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjq  FMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q